A bipartisan group of attorneys general from 43 states and the District of Columbia filed a comment letter Wednesday asking the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to scrap its proposal to define sports event contracts as swaps.
Under the CFTC’s Oct. 9 proposal, event contracts tied to sports, politics, cultural events and weather on prediction markets would explicitly fall under the federal definition of a swap. The agency paired it with an interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling products and traditional sports betting from that definition.
The comment letter lays out four main objections. The states say the CFTC lacks the authority to redefine swaps to cover sports betting, skipped required steps in proposing the rule, failed to justify its reversal or address consumer protection concerns and is interpreting federal law so broadly that it raises constitutional problems.
“A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so,” Ohio Atty. Gen. Andy Wilson, who co-led the coalition, said in a statement. “The agency doesn’t get to invent powers that Congress never gave it, ignore federal court decisions and bulldoze state consumer protections. If Congress wanted the commission running sports gambling, it would have said so — and headquartered it in Las Vegas.”
Which states stepped up vs. out?
Ohio co-led the effort with Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah.
The seven states that did not join the coalition:
- Florida
- Georgia
- Indiana
- Montana
- New Hampshire
- North Dakota
- Texas
States: CFTC stretching swap definition
The states argue that swaps are commonly understood as derivative contracts exchanging cash flows for hedging and price discovery, and sports bets don’t fit that definition. The letter uses the example of an event contract on the New York Knicks winning the NBA Finals.
“This bet does not exchange cash flows or liabilities of financial instruments,” the letter said. “It does not send price signals.”
The states also dismissed the CFTC’s point that designated contract markets have self-certified thousands of sports contracts, saying that logic would let any contract become a swap.
“If no one understands a sports bet to be a swap, it does not magically become a swap just because it is moved to a DCM,” the states wrote.
The letter also called out a contradiction in the CFTC’s own rulemaking. The interim final rule says traditional sportsbook wagers are not swaps, while the proposal says sports event contracts on DCMs are.
The states pointed to CME Group Chairman and CEO Terry Duffy, who has said “sports contracts are gambling, and should be regulated by the states.”
Did the CFTC skip a step?
The coalition also argued the CFTC skipped a required step. Federal law requires the CFTC to further define swaps jointly with the Securities and Exchange Commission, in consultation with the Federal Reserve Board. Only the CFTC signed the proposal, and the SEC’s involvement is mentioned in a single footnote, according to the letter.
“There is no evidence that the SEC had any involvement with the Proposed Rule,” the coalition wrote. “Nor is there evidence that the CFTC consulted with the Federal Reserve Board.”
The states also invoked the major questions doctrine, arguing that a shift in sports betting oversight this large requires clear authorization from Congress. They pointed to the Supreme Court’s 2018 decision in Murphy v. NCAA, which left the choice to legalize sports betting to the states.
Quorum and court losses cloud the rule
The CFTC is designed to have five commissioners, with no more than three from one party. However, Chairman Mike Selig has been the only commissioner since his appointment in December 2025.
The coalition argued that more than one commissioner is needed to act and that finalizing the rule without a quorum would be unlawful. President Donald Trump nominated Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland last week to join Selig.
“A single commissioner does not qualify as ‘Commissioners,’” the coalition wrote. … “Chairman Selig does not have the authority to promulgate a rule until the President nominates and the Senate confirms additional commissioners.”
The letter also cited the Sixth and Ninth Circuit rulings that reached the same conclusion. Both courts held that the CEA does not cover sports event contracts and therefore does not preempt state gambling laws. The states argue an agency can’t override a court’s reading of its authority, so the rule could not apply in either circuit.
Even if the rule is finalized, the states argue it could only apply going forward because federal law doesn’t authorize the CFTC to make the swap definition retroactive.
“This means that the States are free to regulate and bring enforcement actions against prediction markets for any sports-gambling event contracts they offered prior to this rule,” the letter said.
States raise consumer protection concerns
The states argued the CFTC acknowledged the risks of event contracts in its proposal, including loss chasing, addiction and financial harm. However, it never explained why the rule is justified despite them.
“The CFTC brushes aside these concerns,” the coalition wrote. “… And it does not include any safety regulations to tackle this problem.”
The rule includes no age limits, self-exclusion programs or licensing requirements for platforms offering sports contracts, according to the letter. That stands in contrast to state regulations, as many states limit sports betting to those 21 and older, require operators to obtain licenses and run voluntary exclusion programs for problem gamblers, like Ohio’s.
The coalition also took aim at prediction markets allowing 18-year-olds to trade, citing a Citizens report showing nearly a quarter of Kalshi users are under 25, compared to 7% for state regulated sportsbooks.
The states also warned that the proposal could push licensed sportsbooks, such as DraftKings, FanDuel and Fanatics, to reorganize as DCMs and “wind down” their state licenses. That would move more sports betting away from state oversight and leave state consumer without protections.
The coalition also argued the CFTC reversed its longstanding position without explanation, pointing to its 2011 rule barring DCMs from listing gaming contracts and its 2024 statement that it “is not a gaming regulator.” The states said they, operators, consumers and even prior commissioners relied on that stance.
The CFTC is “turning itself not just into a commodities-and-derivatives regulator, but also a national sportsbook and gaming administrator,” the letter said.