Louisiana Prediction Market Battle Ramps Up As Operators, CFTC Strike Quickly

prediction market

Written By:

Published on:

A string of prediction market litigation that began last week with Louisiana Atty. Gen. Liz Murrill suing 32 entities associated with 13 prediction market brands has continued to grow in volume and scope.

The initial prediction markets involved include Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, and Coinbase, amongst others. The lawsuit was followed hours later by an ex parte temporary restraining order from Judge Jeffrey Johnson of the 21st Judicial District Court in Tangipahoa Parish.

Since then, some of those operators and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission have challenged the order in one way or another.

The order covers a wide range of contracts, including sports, elections, awards, and more. It prohibits the defendants from offering or facilitating event contracts for Louisiana customers without state gaming authorization, in addition to requiring the platforms to geofence Louisiana and barring them from representing that their products are authorized in the state.

Kalshi, Polymarket sued first

Kalshi moved first against the state, filing a preemptive federal lawsuit on Oct. 23. The company argued that federal regulators, rather than Louisiana gambling authorities, have jurisdiction over its event contracts because it operates as a federally designated contract market.

More recently, on the same day Murrill filed her state lawsuit, Kalshi filed a motion seeking a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction in its existing federal case. The request for a temporary restraining order was withdrawn by Kalshi at a Friday status conference, but the request for the preliminary injunction was maintained. In this case, Louisiana’s response is due Nov. 18, with Kalshi’s reply due Nov. 20. A hearing is scheduled for Nov. 23.

Separately, Polymarket’s US operator, QCX LLC, also filed a preemptive lawsuit against Louisiana officials on Oct. 27. The company seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, similarly arguing that Louisiana cannot regulate its federally regulated event contracts through state gambling laws.

Polymarket wants to be in federal court

Polymarket US moved Louisiana’s enforcement case to federal court on Friday, filing a notice of removal that transferred the lawsuit from Tangipahoa Parish to the Eastern District of Louisiana.

Moving the case to federal court does not automatically lift the restraining order, and it remains in effect unless the federal court dissolves or modifies it. So far, this has not happened.

Louisiana responded Monday with an emergency motion to have the case returned to state court. So far, nothing has moved beyond this filing.

Robinhood and Rothera Exchange and Clearing challenged the restraining order in separate motions filed Saturday. Both companies want the restrictions lifted or narrowed and requested expedited hearings. Robinhood also asked the court to schedule oral arguments.

The companies argue that Louisiana lacks authority to regulate their federally supervised derivatives products. They also contended that the restraining order is too broad and that they want the federal court to lift or narrow its restrictions.

Separately, the United States/CFTC case was transferred Monday to Judge Lance Africk, same as the removed Louisiana enforcement case. Louisiana subsequently asked Judge Africk to put the federal government’s lawsuit on hold until related enforcement proceedings are resolved. Alternatively, the state requested more time to respond to the government’s motion for emergency relief.

CFTC backs prediction market operators

Outside of the lawsuits filed by Louisiana and the operators, the United States and the CFTC filed their own lawsuit against Louisiana Friday. The lawsuit sits in the Eastern District and seeks a declaration that Louisiana’s gambling laws are preempted by the federal Commodity Exchange Act when applied to event contracts traded on CFTC-regulated exchanges.

In addition to that declaration, the federal government also wants preliminary and permanent injunctive relief preventing Louisiana from enforcing its laws against those exchanges, including the original temporary restraining order.

In a press release, CFTC Chairman Michael Selig described the state lawsuit as “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt.”

Along with the lawsuit, the federal government also sought its own temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. In other words, the federal government is seeking immediate relief from the state’s enforcement actions. This motion was filed on Nov. 13, the same day as the lawsuit, and carries a Nov. 17 submission date on the docket.

Two groups, consisting of Underdog Prediction entities, North American Derivatives Exchange, Crypto.com entities and associated Foris companies, filed motions to intervene on the same day. These motions are simply requests to participate in the litigation.

Louisiana is now embroiled in:

  • four separate lawsuits
  • two granted or pending restraining orders
  • three preliminary injunction requests
  • two motions to dissolve the granted restraining order
  • one emergency motion to remand
  • and two motions to intervene.

New state, same prediction market fight

All of this litigation follows similar patterns across the country, and essentially boils down to the same relatively simple argument that sits at the base of the debate.

Louisiana argues that the operators are offering gambling products without the required state gaming licenses, and that event contracts should be subject to state sports betting laws. The federal government argues that Louisiana cannot use state gambling laws to interfere with the operation of federally regulated derivatives markets. Prediction market operators argue that their products are derivatives traded on federally regulated exchanges, and that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over those markets.

The Coalition for Prediction Markets, which represents several of the operators named in Louisiana’s lawsuit, has also pushed back against comparisons with traditional gambling products.

“Derivatives markets are not slot machines or predatory sportsbooks that hook losers and ban winners,” a spokesperson said.

The implications of these cases could affect the prediction market industry nationwide and help to establish how far states can go in terms of regulating event contracts on federally regulated exchanges.

Photo by Shutterstock/bodhichita